Understanding PBIS and MTSS: A Comprehensive Comparison

Social Emotional Learning (SEL) plays a crucial role in the development of students’ emotional well-being, interpersonal skills, and academic success. As educators and parents, it is essential to understand the frameworks and approaches that support SEL in schools and communities. In this blog post, we will delve into two prominent frameworks in SEL: Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS) and Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS). By understanding the difference between PBIS and MTSS, we can better support students’ social and emotional growth.

I. Introduction

Social Emotional Learning (SEL) is the process through which individuals acquire and apply the knowledge, attitudes, and skills necessary to understand and manage emotions, set and achieve positive goals, feel and show empathy for others, establish and maintain positive relationships, and make responsible decisions. SEL is not only important for individual well-being but also for creating a positive and inclusive school and community environment.

PBIS and MTSS are two frameworks that schools and districts can implement to support SEL. These frameworks provide a systematic approach to promoting positive behavior, addressing challenging behaviors, and providing targeted interventions for students who need additional support.

II. Understanding PBIS (Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports)

PBIS is a proactive approach to establishing the behavioral supports and social culture needed for all students to achieve social, emotional, and academic success. The primary goal of PBIS is to create a positive and safe school climate where students can thrive.

Key components of PBIS include:

1. Universal level: This level focuses on implementing strategies and practices that benefit all students, such as teaching social skills, establishing clear expectations, and reinforcing positive behaviors.
2. Targeted level: This level provides additional supports and interventions for students who are at risk of developing behavioral challenges. It involves targeted interventions and small group supports.
3. Intensive level: This level provides individualized and intensive interventions for students who require more support. It may involve specialized services, counseling, or behavior plans.

The implementation process of PBIS involves:

1. Team formation and commitment: A team of educators, administrators, and support staff is formed to lead the implementation of PBIS. This team is responsible for creating a shared vision, establishing goals, and ensuring fidelity of implementation.
2. Data collection and analysis: Data is collected to identify areas of need, establish baseline measures, and monitor progress. This data-driven approach helps inform decision-making and intervention strategies.
3. Setting clear expectations and rules: Clear and concise behavior expectations and rules are established and communicated to all students. These expectations are taught explicitly and consistently reinforced.
4. Teaching and reinforcing positive behaviors: Students are taught social skills and positive behaviors through explicit instruction, modeling, and practice. Positive reinforcement strategies are used to acknowledge and reward desired behaviors.
5. Monitoring and evaluating progress: Ongoing monitoring and evaluation of the implementation process and outcomes are essential to ensure fidelity and make necessary adjustments.

III. Understanding MTSS (Multi-Tiered System of Supports)

MTSS is a comprehensive framework that integrates academic and behavioral supports to meet the needs of all students. It provides a tiered system of interventions and services, allowing for early identification and intervention for students who require additional support.

Key components of MTSS include:

1. Tier 1: Universal supports: This tier focuses on providing high-quality instruction and support to all students. It includes evidence-based practices, differentiated instruction, and a positive school climate.
2. Tier 2: Targeted supports: This tier provides additional interventions and supports for students who require more targeted assistance. It may involve small group interventions, check-in/check-out systems, or social skills groups.
3. Tier 3: Intensive supports: This tier provides individualized and intensive interventions for students who require the highest level of support. It may involve specialized services, individual counseling, or behavior intervention plans.

The implementation process of MTSS involves:

1. Data-based decision making: Data is collected and analyzed to identify students’ needs, establish baseline measures, and monitor progress. This data-driven approach helps inform decision-making and intervention strategies.
2. Progress monitoring and assessment: Ongoing progress monitoring and assessment are conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of interventions and make data-informed decisions.
3. Evidence-based interventions: Interventions and strategies are selected based on research and evidence of effectiveness. These interventions are implemented with fidelity and monitored for progress.
4. Collaboration and communication among stakeholders: Collaboration and communication among educators, administrators, support staff, and families are essential for successful implementation of MTSS. Regular meetings and sharing of information ensure a coordinated and integrated approach.

IV. Comparison between PBIS and MTSS

While PBIS and MTSS share some common features, they also have distinct differences in scope and application. Understanding these differences can help educators and stakeholders choose the most appropriate framework for their specific needs.

Overlapping features:

1. Focus on prevention and early intervention: Both PBIS and MTSS emphasize the importance of prevention and early intervention. By addressing behavioral and academic challenges proactively, schools can create a positive and supportive environment for all students.
2. Data-driven decision making: Both frameworks rely on data collection and analysis to inform decision-making. By using data, educators can identify areas of need, monitor progress, and make informed decisions about interventions and supports.
3. Collaborative approach: Both PBIS and MTSS require collaboration and communication among stakeholders. Educators, administrators, support staff, and families work together to implement the frameworks effectively and ensure the success of all students.

Differences in scope and application:

1. PBIS primarily focuses on behavior management: PBIS is primarily focused on creating a positive and safe school climate through behavior management strategies. It aims to prevent challenging behaviors and promote positive behaviors through clear expectations, teaching social skills, and reinforcing desired behaviors.
2. MTSS encompasses a broader range of academic and behavioral supports: MTSS is a comprehensive framework that integrates academic and behavioral supports. It addresses the needs of all students, including those who require additional academic interventions. MTSS provides a tiered system of supports that includes high-quality instruction, targeted interventions, and intensive supports.

Integration of PBIS and MTSS:

While PBIS and MTSS can be implemented independently, integrating both frameworks can provide a more comprehensive and holistic approach to supporting students’ social, emotional, and academic needs.

Benefits of combining both frameworks include:

• Enhanced collaboration and coordination among educators and stakeholders
• More comprehensive and integrated supports for students
• Improved data collection and analysis for informed decision-making
• Increased alignment between academic and behavioral interventions

Strategies for integrating PBIS and MTSS effectively:

• Establish a shared vision and goals for SEL implementation
• Ensure clear communication and collaboration among stakeholders
• Align PBIS and MTSS practices and interventions
• Provide professional development and training for educators
• Monitor and evaluate the integration process for continuous improvement

V. Conclusion

In conclusion, PBIS and MTSS are two frameworks that support Social Emotional Learning (SEL) in schools and communities. PBIS focuses primarily on behavior management, while MTSS encompasses a broader range of academic and behavioral supports. By understanding the difference between PBIS and MTSS, educators and stakeholders can make informed decisions about implementing the most appropriate framework for their specific needs.

It is essential to explore further resources and seek professional guidance to effectively implement PBIS, MTSS, or a combination of both frameworks. Start your EverydaySpeech Free trial today to access a wide range of resources and support for SEL implementation in your school or district.

Start your EverydaySpeech Free trial